Study Questions Payers’ Bargaining Chops Amid Big Variations in Primary Care Costs

  • Jan 24, 2025

    Commercial insurers pay significantly more for routine office visits conducted by primary care providers (PCPs) employed by hospitals or private equity firms than what they pay to PCPs working for independent practices, according to an analysis published on Jan. 17 in JAMA Health Forum. Yashaswini Singh, Ph.D., the study’s lead author, says the prices were similar regardless of the insurer, indicating that even major payers are “not exerting downward bargaining pressure in these price negotiations.”  

    Singh adds that one “plausible explanation” for the high prices paid to PCPs at hospital- or PE-owned facilities is that those provider groups have market power because there are fewer competitors in their geographic areas. She suggests that another potential reason for the discrepancy is that “insurers can just pass on any price increases that they themselves experience to consumers” via higher out-of-pocket expenses. As such, she says “there may be less of an incentive to negotiate favorable rates,” although she points out the authors did not “directly examine either of those explanations for price differentials in this study.” 

    Read more
    © 2024 MMIT
  • Tim Casey

    Tim has been a reporter and editor for newspapers, websites and magazines for more than 20 years, including 10 years covering health care business topics. He has a deep knowledge of the managed care industry and pharmacy benefit management. He also has experience covering medical conferences and clinical and legislative health care issues. In 2014, the Society for Advancing Business Editing and Writing selected Tim as one of 15 journalists to participate in a national symposium on the Affordable Care Act. Tim has a B.A. in Psychology from the University of Notre Dame and an M.B.A. from Georgetown University.

The Latest
Meet Our Reporters

Meet Our Reporters

×